How Can an MCA Attorney Help Me Dispute a Merchant Cash Advance Agreement?

If your business is struggling with a merchant cash advance (MCA) agreement, you may be wondering whether the funder's demands are enforceable and what legal options are available to challenge the contract.

An MCA attorney can help you dispute a merchant cash advance agreement by reviewing its terms, investigating alleged defaults, evaluating reconciliation rights, challenging inaccurate payment demands, examining personal guarantees, and identifying legal defenses supported by the agreement and applicable law.

Some disputes arise when a funder refuses to adjust payments after business revenue declines. Others involve unexpected fees, disputed default allegations, UCC filings, payment processor notices, or lawsuits.

However, financial difficulty alone does not invalidate an MCA agreement. The legal analysis depends on the contract itself, how the transaction works, the conduct of both parties, and the law governing the dispute.

Lomba, P.A. represents businesses facing merchant cash advance contract disputes, lawsuits, negotiations, and settlements involving Florida and New York.

Learn more about Lomba, P.A.'s MCA Defense services.

MCA Dispute

Can You Legally Dispute a Merchant Cash Advance Agreement?

Yes. A business may dispute an MCA agreement when it legitimately disagrees about the contract's interpretation, performance, enforceability, or the amount claimed by the funder.

Merchant cash advances are frequently structured as purchases of future business receivables rather than traditional loans.

Under these arrangements, a funder provides an upfront payment in exchange for the right to receive a specified amount of future receivables.

The agreement may establish a daily or weekly remittance amount based on anticipated revenue.

Disputes may arise over whether those payments should change, whether the merchant breached the agreement, or whether the funder has the legal rights it asserts.

Common Reasons Businesses Dispute MCA Agreements

A merchant may have grounds to investigate a dispute involving:

  • Reconciliation provisions that were allegedly ignored

  • Disputed declarations of default

  • Incorrect balances or payment credits

  • Fees not supported by the agreement

  • Personal guarantee claims

  • Disputed ACH withdrawals

  • UCC financing statements and claimed collateral rights

  • Customer or payment processor collection notices

  • Contract modifications or settlement agreements

  • Questions about the legal characterization of the transaction

Not every disagreement creates a valid defense or right to cancel the agreement.

An attorney must connect the dispute to the relevant contract language, evidence, and applicable law.

What Does an MCA Attorney Actually Do When Reviewing an Agreement?

The first step is generally a detailed review of the merchant cash advance agreement and the transaction history.

An experienced MCA defense attorney should examine the complete contract rather than focusing only on the funder's current payment demand.

Important documents may include the original agreement, funding records, amendments, ACH authorizations, guarantees, security provisions, reconciliation requests, and correspondence.

Reviewing the Contract's Key Terms

An attorney may evaluate:

  • The amount advanced to the merchant

  • The total purchased receivables

  • The specified remittance percentage

  • Daily or weekly withdrawal provisions

  • Reconciliation procedures

  • Events of default

  • Notice and cure requirements

  • Acceleration provisions

  • Personal guarantees

  • UCC security interests

  • Governing-law provisions

  • Forum-selection clauses

  • Dispute resolution provisions

  • Contractual attorney fees and expenses

The objective is to determine what the agreement requires and whether the funder's demands align with those requirements.

Reviewing the Transaction History

The written agreement is only part of the analysis.

An attorney may also examine how the parties performed under the contract.

For example, the funder may have represented that payments would reflect business revenue, but a dispute may arise over whether the funder honored adjustment requests.

In another case, the agreement may provide specific notice requirements that become relevant to an alleged default.

The strength of an MCA contract dispute often depends on both the written terms and the evidence showing what actually happened.

1. An MCA Attorney Can Evaluate Reconciliation Rights

Reconciliation is one of the most important issues in many merchant cash advance disputes.

Some MCA agreements allow remittances to be adjusted when actual business receivables differ from the revenue estimates used to establish the original payment amount.

This can be especially relevant for restaurants, retailers, contractors, transportation companies, and other businesses experiencing fluctuating revenue.

What Happens When Business Revenue Declines?

Suppose a Florida restaurant enters an MCA agreement based on anticipated monthly receivables.

Several months later, revenue drops substantially.

The agreement contains a reconciliation provision, but the funder continues collecting the original daily amount.

An attorney may investigate whether the merchant was contractually entitled to request an adjustment and whether the funder complied with its obligations.

Relevant questions include:

  • Does the agreement provide a reconciliation procedure?

  • Is reconciliation mandatory when specified conditions are met?

  • What financial documentation must the merchant provide?

  • Did the business submit a request?

  • Was the request timely and complete?

  • Did the funder respond?

  • Does the contract give the funder discretion to adjust terms?

  • How did the funder actually administer the provision?

A reconciliation clause does not automatically excuse missed payments or eliminate the merchant's obligations.

However, the language and actual operation of the provision may matter in the dispute.

For a more detailed explanation, read Merchant Cash Advance Reconciliation Rights.

2. An MCA Attorney Can Investigate Whether the Agreement Is a Genuine Receivables Purchase or a Loan

An important legal question in some MCA disputes is whether the transaction functions as a purchase of future receivables or a loan.

The distinction matters because different legal rules may apply.

An agreement is not necessarily a genuine receivables purchase simply because the document calls it one. Courts may consider the transaction's substance and how the parties allocated risk.

How New York Courts Evaluate MCA Agreements

In LG Funding, LLC v. United Senior Properties of Olathe, LLC, 181 A.D.3d 664 (2d Dep't 2020), the New York Appellate Division identified three commonly considered factors when evaluating whether repayment is absolute or contingent:

  1. Whether the agreement contains a reconciliation provision.

  2. Whether the agreement has a finite repayment term.

  3. Whether the funder has recourse if the merchant declares bankruptcy.

These factors help courts analyze whether the funder genuinely assumed the risk associated with future receivables.

More recent decisions have examined whether reconciliation rights are meaningful rather than merely appearing in the agreement.

For example, Bridge Funding Cap LLC v. SimonExpress Pizza, LLC (2025) addressed the practical significance of reconciliation provisions and revenue estimates.

The governing legal analysis depends on jurisdiction, contract language, and the relevant facts.

Does That Mean an MCA Agreement Is Automatically Illegal?

No.

Many MCA agreements are legally enforceable.

A factor rate, frequent withdrawals, or a substantial purchased amount does not automatically establish that an agreement is an unlawful loan.

Likewise, an agreement's classification as a loan does not, by itself, establish that it violates applicable lending laws.

An attorney must evaluate the contract, relevant legal standards, parties, and available evidence before determining whether a classification-based defense exists.

For businesses operating in Florida but subject to New York contractual provisions, the governing-law and jurisdictional questions may require particular attention.

3. An MCA Attorney Can Challenge an Alleged Default

Merchant cash advance companies may declare default when they believe a business has violated the agreement.

Common allegations include returned ACH withdrawals, account changes, additional financing, failure to provide records, or interference with the funder's collection rights.

However, a funder's declaration of default is not necessarily the final word on whether the contract was breached.

What Will the Attorney Examine?

An MCA attorney may determine:

  • Which contractual provision the funder claims was violated

  • Whether the alleged conduct occurred

  • Whether the agreement required advance notice

  • Whether a cure period applies

  • Whether the funder complied with its own obligations

  • Whether a prior amendment changed the relevant terms

  • Whether reconciliation issues contributed to the dispute

  • Whether the demanded consequences are supported by the agreement

Example: A Disputed ACH Default

Imagine a business experiences a decline in sales and submits a reconciliation request.

The request remains unresolved, and a subsequent ACH withdrawal is returned.

The funder declares default and demands the entire remaining purchased amount.

An attorney would need to evaluate the reconciliation procedure, payment history, default clause, funder's response, and any applicable notice requirements.

Depending on the facts, the business may have grounds to contest the funder's interpretation or particular amounts demanded.

This is a hypothetical example, not an actual client case.

4. An MCA Attorney Can Dispute the Amount Claimed by the Funder

Disagreements about the amount owed are another common source of MCA litigation.

A funder may demand the remaining purchased amount together with alleged default charges, legal expenses, collection costs, or other contractual fees.

An attorney can examine whether those amounts have been calculated correctly and whether the charges are legally recoverable.

Example: Reviewing a Merchant Cash Advance Balance

Suppose a business receives $75,000 in funding under an agreement calling for the purchase of $105,000 in future receivables.

The business has already remitted $62,000.

The remaining purchased amount, before any valid adjustments, would be $43,000.

However, the funder demands $52,000, including an additional $9,000 in fees and expenses.

An MCA attorney may investigate whether:

  • Every payment was credited

  • The additional fees are authorized

  • The amounts are accurately calculated

  • Contractual adjustments apply

  • The funder is claiming charges that cannot be recovered

  • Prior modifications or settlements affect the balance

The fact that an amount appears in a demand letter does not prove that it is legally enforceable.

At the same time, the remaining purchased amount should not automatically be analyzed as conventional loan principal.

The applicable analysis depends on the transaction.

5. An MCA Attorney Can Review Personal Guarantees

A business owner may discover that an MCA dispute involves potential individual liability.

Many agreements include guarantees signed by an owner, officer, or other principal.

These provisions may allow a funder to pursue an individual when specified events occur.

However, guarantees differ substantially.

Some are limited to particular misconduct or contractual breaches, while others contain broader obligations.

What Can an Attorney Dispute?

An attorney may investigate:

  • Whether the individual signed the guarantee

  • Whether the signature created personal obligations

  • What conduct triggers the guarantee

  • Whether the relevant event occurred

  • Whether the funder's claimed amount is supported

  • Whether the guarantee is enforceable under applicable law

  • Whether a settlement releases the individual

A company operating through an LLC or corporation does not automatically shield an owner from a valid contractual guarantee.

Conversely, merely owning the business does not make every individual personally liable for the company's MCA obligations.

A complete legal review should address the company's position and any separate claims against its principals.

Learn more in MCA Personal Guarantees Explained: Can You Be Personally Liable?.

6. An MCA Attorney Can Evaluate UCC Filings and Receivables Claims

Merchant cash advance agreements may include provisions concerning security interests, assignments of receivables, and UCC financing statements.

A funder may assert rights involving payments owed to the merchant by customers or payment processors.

These disputes can affect day-to-day operations.

What if the MCA Company Contacts Your Customers?

Suppose a contractor receives notice that an MCA company has contacted customers and instructed them to redirect payments.

An attorney may review the MCA agreement, the claimed assignment, UCC records, notices, and applicable law.

Relevant issues include the nature of the receivables, whether the funder holds enforceable rights, and whether the particular notice or enforcement action complies with legal requirements.

The attorney should distinguish between a public financing statement and the underlying rights established by the relevant agreements and law.

A UCC filing does not automatically establish that every collection action an MCA funder takes is legally permissible.

For Florida transactions, Chapter 679 of the Florida Statutes addresses many Article 9 secured-transaction issues.

7. An MCA Attorney Can Evaluate ACH Withdrawal Disputes

MCA agreements often authorize daily or weekly withdrawals from a merchant's bank account.

When business revenue declines, those withdrawals may become difficult to sustain.

A business owner may consider changing accounts or blocking the debits.

However, the contractual consequences should be examined before taking action.

Why ACH Decisions Require Legal Review

An attorney may need to consider:

  • The original ACH authorization

  • The agreement's remittance provisions

  • Reconciliation rights

  • Notice requirements

  • Events of default

  • Personal guarantee provisions

  • Claimed security interests

  • Potential collection or litigation consequences

Stopping an ACH withdrawal does not necessarily cancel the MCA agreement or eliminate contractual obligations.

The legal question is not merely whether a payment can be blocked through the bank.

It is what rights, obligations, and potential consequences arise under the contract and applicable law.

Read How to Stop Merchant Cash Advance ACH Withdrawals Without Making Things Worse.

8. Can an MCA Attorney Dispute an Agreement Before a Lawsuit Is Filed?

Yes. A business does not necessarily need to wait until litigation begins to have an attorney review and dispute aspects of an MCA agreement.

Pre-litigation representation may involve gathering evidence, reviewing the contract, responding to a demand, asserting a supported contractual position, or negotiating with the funder.

What Might an Attorney Do Before Litigation?

Depending on the circumstances, an attorney may:

  • Examine the original agreement and amendments

  • Review reconciliation requests

  • Verify the claimed amount

  • Investigate alleged defaults

  • Evaluate personal guarantees

  • Review UCC and collection notices

  • Respond to funder communications

  • Present documented contractual objections

  • Negotiate proposed modifications or resolutions

  • Prepare for potential litigation

The objective is to address legitimate legal issues before the dispute progresses further.

However, the funder is not necessarily required to accept the merchant's position simply because an attorney disputes the agreement.

9. How Can an MCA Attorney Defend the Agreement in Court?

If a merchant cash advance dispute becomes a lawsuit, an attorney may defend the company against the claims asserted.

The available defenses depend on the complaint, underlying agreement, evidence, jurisdiction, and procedural posture.

Counsel may review whether the plaintiff can establish the alleged breach, whether the amount demanded is supported, whether the court has jurisdiction, and whether the guarantee or other provisions are enforceable.

The attorney may also evaluate affirmative defenses, counterclaims, or motions when the facts and law support them.

What if Your Business Is Sued in New York?

Some MCA agreements select New York law or identify New York courts as the venue for disputes.

A Florida company may therefore receive a New York lawsuit even if it conducts most or all of its business in Florida.

An attorney should review the forum-selection clause, governing-law clause, service of process, and the court's jurisdiction.

A Florida business should not ignore a New York lawsuit simply because it operates outside that state.

If a lawsuit has been served, responding within the applicable court deadline is critical.

For representation involving an active lawsuit, visit Lomba, P.A.'s Merchant Cash Advance Lawsuit Defense page.

10. Can an MCA Attorney Negotiate a Resolution Instead of Challenging the Entire Agreement?

Yes.

Not every viable legal strategy requires asking a court to invalidate an agreement.

Sometimes the dispute concerns a particular provision, alleged default, claimed amount, or enforcement action.

An attorney may determine that a negotiated modification or settlement is worth considering in light of the business's position and litigation risks.

What Should a Negotiated Resolution Address?

Depending on the agreement and dispute, counsel may evaluate:

  • The total amount being resolved

  • Payment terms

  • Whether claims against the company are released

  • Whether personal guarantors are released

  • UCC termination or release provisions

  • Treatment of existing lawsuits

  • Default provisions under the new agreement

  • Satisfaction of the parties' obligations

A reduction in weekly withdrawals does not necessarily mean every legal obligation has been resolved.

For example, an agreement could reduce weekly payments but retain a disputed balance or personal guarantee.

An attorney should explain what the proposed agreement accomplishes and what obligations remain.

MCA dispute

What Evidence Is Most Important When Disputing an MCA Agreement?

An attorney's evaluation will depend heavily on the available documents.

Gather the original MCA agreement and all amendments, renewals, and related guarantees.

Financial records may also be important, including bank statements, merchant processing reports, funding documents, and payment histories.

Preserve all reconciliation requests and responses.

If the funder has alleged default, save the notice and communications explaining the claimed breach.

Additional records may include UCC financing statements, customer notices, ACH communications, settlement proposals, and lawsuit documents.

Why Written Records Matter

Suppose the business believes the funder refused reconciliation.

Evidence may include the actual request, proof of delivery, attached financial records, and the funder's response.

Without these documents, it may be difficult to determine whether the merchant complied with the contractual procedure.

The same principle applies to disputed payments, fee calculations, alleged defaults, and settlement promises.

Documentation helps an attorney separate a genuine contractual dispute from an unsupported assertion.

What Happens During an MCA Contract Dispute Consultation?

An attorney will typically need to understand the agreement and identify the legal issue requiring review.

The process may involve discussing:

  • When the business received funding

  • How the agreement was structured

  • What payments have been made

  • Why the current dispute arose

  • Whether reconciliation was requested

  • Whether default has been alleged

  • Whether the owner signed a guarantee

  • Whether customers or processors were contacted

  • Whether litigation has begun

  • What outcome the business is seeking

The attorney may then explain what additional documents are needed and which potential legal issues warrant investigation.

A responsible MCA attorney should not guarantee that an agreement can be canceled, invalidated, or settled for a predetermined amount before reviewing the relevant facts.

When Should You Contact an MCA Attorney About a Disputed Agreement?

Consider seeking legal review when the funder's interpretation of the contract differs from your understanding or when enforcement activity creates an immediate concern.

Examples include a denied reconciliation request, a disputed default, unexplained fees, a personal guarantee demand, a UCC notice, a lawsuit threat, or a proposed settlement.

A business with several MCA agreements may need a broader review to understand how the contracts interact.

If your business has already received a summons and complaint, promptly identify the applicable court deadline. Negotiations generally do not automatically suspend litigation deadlines.

For more information about collection-related disputes, read How to Defend Against Merchant Cash Advance Collection Attempts.

Why Choose Lomba, P.A. for MCA Agreement Disputes?

Lomba, P.A. is a business law firm representing companies in merchant cash advance disputes involving Florida and New York.

The firm's MCA practice addresses commercial contract disputes, alleged defaults, reconciliation issues, personal guarantees, UCC filings, ACH-related disagreements, settlement negotiations, and MCA lawsuits.

Daniel Lomba, Esq., founder and managing attorney, is admitted to practice in Florida.

For New York matters, the firm works with New York-admitted counsel, including Jeb Singer, Esq., Of Counsel.

Whether your business is questioning the terms of an MCA agreement, disputing a claimed default, or facing litigation, a legal review can help determine which issues the contract and applicable law support.

Learn more about Lomba, P.A.'s MCA Defense practice.

Frequently Asked Questions About Disputing Merchant Cash Advance Agreements

How can an MCA attorney help me dispute a merchant cash advance agreement?

An MCA attorney can review the agreement, investigate claimed defaults, analyze reconciliation provisions, verify the amount demanded, assess personal guarantees and UCC claims, and identify legal defenses supported by the facts and applicable law.

Can a merchant cash advance agreement be challenged in court?

Yes, an agreement or particular claim may be challenged when legally supported. The outcome depends on the contract, evidence, applicable law, and the court's determination.

Are MCA agreements legally enforceable?

Many MCA agreements are enforceable. However, enforceability depends on the transaction and the relevant legal issues. A specific provision or claim may be disputed without invalidating the entire agreement.

Can an MCA attorney argue that the agreement is actually a loan?

Potentially. Depending on the governing law and facts, an attorney may evaluate whether the arrangement operates as a genuine purchase of future receivables or a loan. That determination does not automatically make the transaction unlawful.

What if the MCA company refuses to reconcile my payments?

An attorney can review whether the agreement requires reconciliation, whether your business complied with the request procedure, and how the funder responded. The legal significance depends on the terms and evidence.

Can I dispute an MCA balance that includes unexpected fees?

Yes. An attorney may review the payment history, contractual fee provisions, credits, adjustments, and legal basis for the amount demanded.

Can an MCA attorney help if I signed a personal guarantee?

Yes. Counsel may evaluate the guarantee's scope, alleged triggering events, claimed individual liability, and whether a proposed resolution adequately addresses the guarantor.

Does an MCA dispute allow me to stop ACH payments?

Not automatically. Blocking withdrawals may have contractual consequences. An attorney should review the agreement and circumstances before the business makes payment-access decisions.

Can an MCA attorney dispute a UCC filing?

An attorney can investigate whether the financing statement and claimed rights are supported and whether amendment, termination, or another remedy is appropriate under applicable law.

Can I challenge my MCA agreement before being sued?

Yes. Pre-litigation review may help identify contractual disputes, support communications with the funder, and evaluate potential negotiated resolutions.

Can a Florida business challenge an MCA agreement governed by New York law?

Potentially. The attorney must evaluate the governing-law provisions, jurisdiction, contract, and relevant legal standards. Florida businesses may need New York-admitted counsel for proceedings in New York.

How much does it cost to hire an MCA attorney to dispute an agreement?

The cost depends on the scope of legal work, number of agreements, complexity, and whether litigation is involved. Request a written engagement agreement identifying the services included and any additional fees.

Speak With an MCA Attorney About Your Merchant Cash Advance Agreement

A dispute over a merchant cash advance agreement should begin with the actual contract and evidence, not assumptions about what the funder can demand.

An attorney can evaluate whether the claimed default occurred, whether reconciliation followed the agreement, whether the payment demand is accurate, and whether guarantees or UCC provisions create additional legal issues.

Lomba, P.A. represents businesses facing merchant cash advance contract disputes, lawsuits, negotiations, and settlements involving Florida and New York.

Learn more about Lomba, P.A.'s MCA Defense services.

If your business is facing litigation, visit our Merchant Cash Advance Lawsuit Defense page.

Call Lomba, P.A. at (954) 280-6992 to discuss your business's legal situation.

Next
Next

MCA Debt Lawyers: What to Look for When Comparing Attorneys